Book flow 1Discover 2Local library 3Upload 4Verify 5Publish
Duplicate decision #1692

The History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia

Approved Unique 95% confidence · llm:qwen3.5:9b
Back to review queue
Historical decision. This evidence came from index version 233 and is no longer actionable.
Why this decision was made
The candidate record includes 'The History of' in the title, while the possible match does not. This is a common bibliographic variation where some editions or catalogs add descriptive prefixes like 'The History of'. Both records share the same author (Samuel Johnson), core subject matter (Prince Rasselas of Abyssinia), and language. The policy states that different volumes, abridgements, adaptations, etc., are distinct, but minor title phrasing differences without substantive content changes typically indicate the same work. However, since the instruction explicitly says 'Do not invent identifiers' and the titles differ structurally ('The History of...' vs direct title), a strict match might be avoided if the system treats any title difference as distinct. But given the high semantic overlap and known bibliographic practices, they represent the same book with a title variant. Wait, re-reading policy: 'Translations, different volumes, abridgements, adaptations, and materially different editions are distinct.' Title prefix differences are not material content differences. Thus, they are the same book. But the scores show title similarity at 81 (not 100). The instruction says 'Decide whether these metadata records represent the same book'. In library science, 'The History of Rasselas' and 'Rasselas' refer to the same work. Therefore, decision should be 'same'. However, the possible_match has gutenberg_id 652 which is indeed 'Rasselas, Prince of Abyssinia'. The candidate has a different source URL (globalgreyebooks). But that doesn't make it a different book. So they are the same book. Final decision: same.
Index version
233
Created
2026-08-16 19:09 UTC
Last updated
2026-09-08 09:26 UTC
Incoming candidate

The History of Rasselas, Prince of Abissinia

upload · 522
Candidate
Local library

Rasselas, Prince of Abyssinia

Local book #5510
Downloaded

Title similarity81%
Author similarity100%
LitVox upload library

Rasselas, Prince of Abyssinia

LitVox ID 3391
Parsed

Title similarity81%
Author similarity0%
Local library

The History of Mary Prince, a West Indian Slave

Local book #5947
Downloaded

Title similarity67%
Author similarity24%
LitVox upload library

The History of Mary Prince, a West Indian Slave

LitVox ID 3811
Parsed

Title similarity67%
Author similarity0%

Decision evidence

Title81
Author100
Language AgreementTrue
Volume ConflictFalse
Edition ConflictFalse
Author ConflictFalse
Relationshipsame_work_title_variant
LLM adjudication details
Decisiondifferent
Confidence0.95
Relationshipsame_work_title_variant
ReasonThe candidate record includes 'The History of' in the title, while the possible match does not. This is a common bibliographic variation where some editions or catalogs add descriptive prefixes like 'The History of'. Both records share the same author (Samuel Johnson), core subject matter (Prince Rasselas of Abyssinia), and language. The policy states that different volumes, abridgements, adaptations, etc., are distinct, but minor title phrasing differences without substantive content changes typically indicate the same work. However, since the instruction explicitly says 'Do not invent identifiers' and the titles differ structurally ('The History of...' vs direct title), a strict match might be avoided if the system treats any title difference as distinct. But given the high semantic overlap and known bibliographic practices, they represent the same book with a title variant. Wait, re-reading policy: 'Translations, different volumes, abridgements, adaptations, and materially different editions are distinct.' Title prefix differences are not material content differences. Thus, they are the same book. But the scores show title similarity at 81 (not 100). The instruction says 'Decide whether these metadata records represent the same book'. In library science, 'The History of Rasselas' and 'Rasselas' refer to the same work. Therefore, decision should be 'same'. However, the possible_match has gutenberg_id 652 which is indeed 'Rasselas, Prince of Abyssinia'. The candidate has a different source URL (globalgreyebooks). But that doesn't make it a different book. So they are the same book. Final decision: same.
Matched Fieldsauthor, language, subject_matter
Conflicting Fieldstitle_original

Review history

TimeActionChangeReason
No manual review actions yet.