Duplicate decision #1650

The Woodlanders

Approved Unique 98% confidence · llm:qwen3.5:9b

Historical decision. This evidence came from index version 233 and is no longer actionable.

Why this decision was made

The records represent two entirely different books: 'The Woodlanders' by Thomas Hardy (a novel about class divisions in a village) and 'Woodland Tales' by Ernest Thompson Seton (a collection of nature fables for children). The title similarity is coincidental, the authors are different, and the descriptions describe completely different content.

Index version: 233
Created: 2026-08-16 19:07 UTC
Last updated: 2026-09-08 09:24 UTC

Incoming candidate

The Woodlanders

upload · 478

Candidate

Authors: Thomas Hardy
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Source identifier: Not provided
Gutenberg ID: Not provided
Source URL: https://www.globalgreyebooks.com/ebooks/thomas-hardy_woodlanders.epub
Description: Set in the secluded woodland village of Little Hintock, Thomas Hardy's *The Woodlanders* explores the rigid class divisions between the educated outsider and the rustic inhabitants. Through the return of the educated Grace Melbury and the tragic romance of Giles Winterborne, the novel examines the tension between tradition and progress, love and duty, and the enduring power of the natural world against human ambition.

Local library

Woodland Tales

Local book #3533

Downloaded

Authors: Ernest Thompson Seton
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 23667
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg23667.epub File present
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/23667.epub.noimages
Description: Ernest Thompson Seton's "Woodland Tales" invites children and adults into a magical world where nature's secrets come to life through fable. Blending fairy tale charm with educational woodcraft, the book reveals the stories behind animals, plants, and natural phenomena, encouraging observation, respect for the wild, and a deep connection to the outdoors.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity80%

Author similarity42%

Upload queue

Woodland Tales

Local book #3533

Queued

Authors: Ernest Thompson Seton
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 23667
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg23667.epub File present
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/23667.epub.noimages
Description: Ernest Thompson Seton's "Woodland Tales" invites children and adults into a magical world where nature's secrets come to life through fable. Blending fairy tale charm with educational woodcraft, the book reveals the stories behind animals, plants, and natural phenomena, encouraging observation, respect for the wild, and a deep connection to the outdoors.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity80%

Author similarity42%

Local library

The Good Soldier

Local book #1054

Downloaded

Authors: Ford Madox Ford
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Local EPUB: data/epubs/url-85454dce61a2b703.epub File present
Source URL: https://www.globalgreyebooks.com/ebooks/ford-madox-ford_good-soldier.epub
Description: Set among wealthy expatriates in Europe, this psychologically complex novel explores love, deception, and emotional repression through an unreliable narrator. As fragmented memories reveal hidden affairs and moral collapse, the story questions the stability of seemingly perfect lives and the nature of truth in a society obsessed with appearances.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity71%

Author similarity45%

Local library

The woman of Andros

Local book #1707

Downloaded

Authors: Thornton Wilder
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 78024
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg78024.epub File missing
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/78024.epub.noimages
Description: Set in ancient Greece, this novel explores themes of love, loss, and the human condition through the intertwined lives of a merchant, his son, and a mysterious woman from Andros. Wilder's lyrical prose blends classical tragedy with modern psychological insight, offering a poignant meditation on suffering, resilience, and the enduring power of love against societal constraints.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity73%

Author similarity37%

Local library

The Wonder

Local book #5999

Downloaded

Authors: J. D. Beresford
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 27188
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg27188.epub File present
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/27188.epub.noimages
Description: In a world where a bald, silent infant named Victor Stott possesses an uncanny intelligence that unnerves adults, a journalist-narrator documents the boy's terrifying yet fascinating journey from a railway carriage to a life of profound isolation. As Victor's supernatural abilities grow, he challenges the boundaries of human knowledge and sanity, leading to a tragic conclusion that forces the narrator to confront the limits of science and the necessity of mystery.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity78%

Author similarity24%

Upload queue

The Wonder

Local book #5999

Queued

Authors: J. D. Beresford
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 27188
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg27188.epub File present
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/27188.epub.noimages
Description: In a world where a bald, silent infant named Victor Stott possesses an uncanny intelligence that unnerves adults, a journalist-narrator documents the boy's terrifying yet fascinating journey from a railway carriage to a life of profound isolation. As Victor's supernatural abilities grow, he challenges the boundaries of human knowledge and sanity, leading to a tragic conclusion that forces the narrator to confront the limits of science and the necessity of mystery.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity78%

Author similarity24%

Local library

The Old Lady flies

Local book #1854

Downloaded

Authors: Raoul Whitfield
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 78035
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg78035.epub File missing
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/78035.epub.noimages
Description: In the 1920s, sentimental flyer Russ Healy refuses to retire his beloved, dilapidated Jenny biplane despite his boss's orders. When the circus faces financial trouble, Russ defies logic and safety protocols to prove the 'Old Lady' still has spirit. His stubbornness leads to a chaotic confrontation with a film crew, resulting in a staged aerial dogfight that tests the limits of friendship, business, and the enduring bond between a pilot and his machine.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity69%

Author similarity30%

Upload queue

The book of wonders

Local book #5639

Queued

Authors: 1726 downloads
Language: english
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
Gutenberg ID: 75948
Local EPUB: data/epubs/pg75948.epub File present
Source URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/75948.epub.noimages
Description: Edited and arranged by Rudolph J. Bodmer, this 1915 educational volume answers thousands of everyday questions with plain, simple explanations. Featuring hundreds of illustrations, it explores the wonders of nature and human engineering, covering topics from cement and concrete to ancient rope-making and the elements of carbon and salt.

View exact record Open source

Title similarity67%

Author similarity31%

LitVox upload library

The woman of Andros

LitVox ID 2415

Parsed

Authors: Unknown author
Language: Unknown
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
LitVox UUID: 66be4bc378b7
Gutenberg ID: 78024

View exact record

Title similarity73%

Author similarity0%

LitVox upload library

The Old Lady flies

LitVox ID 2505

Parsed

Authors: Unknown author
Language: Unknown
Volume or part: None detected
Edition markers: None detected
LitVox UUID: d1058775e212
Gutenberg ID: 78035

View exact record

Title similarity69%

Author similarity0%

Decision evidence

Title	80
Author	42
Language Agreement	True
Volume Conflict	False
Edition Conflict	False
Author Conflict	False
Relationship	different_edition

LLM adjudication details

Decision	different
Confidence	0.98
Relationship	different_edition
Reason	The records represent two entirely different books: 'The Woodlanders' by Thomas Hardy (a novel about class divisions in a village) and 'Woodland Tales' by Ernest Thompson Seton (a collection of nature fables for children). The title similarity is coincidental, the authors are different, and the descriptions describe completely different content.
Matched Fields	language
Conflicting Fields	title_original, authors_original, description

Review history

Time	Action	Change	Reason
No manual review actions yet.